Two prediction markets that facilitate sports gambling reportedly asked 35 states to share their confidential online gambling self-exclusion lists.
The firms, Kalshi and Novig, claim states could help people with addiction by sharing these lists with the startups. Both companies are in contentious legal disputes with numerous states, which say prediction markets are illegal gambling, while the platforms say federal law authorizes their bets. Federal appellate courts have so far mostly sided with the states, with a likely Supreme Court intervention in the near future.
Bloomberg’s Bobby Allyn reported on the Kalshi-Novig letter to the states.
Would It Be Legal?
State gambling laws vary. Still, under existing laws in many states, sharing a full self-exclusion list with a prediction market without the individuals’ consent would likely be unlawful. Could prediction markets qualify as an authorized recipient under a specific state’s laws? Probably not.
In Pennsylvania, gambling regulations prohibit disclosing its self-exclusion list to unauthorized recipients. Ohio similarly restricts release of these records, except at an individual’s request and with regulatory approval. What legal authority would allow either state to transfer its full list to Kalshi or Novig?
It’s unclear whether the CFTC, the federal agency backing prediction markets in court fights, would regulate how firms use these self-exclusion databases, which typically contain thousands of people per state.
State-licensed sportsbooks are generally prohibited from sending promotions to self-excluded people. Would the CFTC ensure these sensitive databases are used only to prevent gambling, not for marketing, customer profiling, or other commercial purposes? What other regulatory agency might investigate violations and impose penalties?
States could expose people with histories of addiction to commercial exploitation or other potential misuse of their personal information.
Analysis
The Kalshi-Novig letter appears unserious and like legal trolling. It’s an audacious request amid legal fights over the legality of prediction-market-style sports betting.
Attorneys for the firms wrote:
“We believe a person’s choice to self-exclude should not depend on where they live or which regulator oversees a platform. Today’s patchwork of separate state lists leaves gaps that at-risk people can fall through.”
Indeed, there are major shortcomings in how self-exclusion works state by state. Some regulators and policymakers have acknowledged that problem. Advocates say a federal bill could be useful.
The SAFE Bet Act of 2025 calls for establishing a national sports betting self-exclusion list.
The legislation, introduced by Rep. Paul Tonko (D-NY) and Sen. Richard Blumenthal (D-CT), would direct the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, working with state gambling regulators, to establish and administer a national database.
In March 2026, Blumenthal introduced the Prediction Markets Security and Integrity Act. A provision would establish a national self-exclusion list under HHS specifically covering online prediction markets.
Congress has already been presented with a possible national self-exclusion solution under federal public-health oversight. That stands in stark contrast to states handing over confidential databases to companies that argue state gambling laws do not apply to them.













